Tuesday 17 September 2024

A Voracious Reader

 I must admit that when someone tells me they're a 'voracious reader', always with his or (more commonly) her nose in a book, my heart sinks a little. I know this self-description will nearly always mean that s/he is a compulsive reader of contemporary (or genre) fiction, and that we are unlikely to have more than a couple of titles in common. Here is a description of a 'voracious reader' from a slightly earlier time, one whose identity might come as a surprise: 
'Reading, for which he had a voracious appetite, was his chief relaxation and recreation. He read all the current English and American fiction as it became available from the Harrods Lending Library, most of which must have been by his lights pretty dismal stuff. The only writers he refused to read were Simenon and C.P. Snow. On average, he must have got through about eight books a week and sometimes my mother changed their two library books daily, to the despair of wide-eyed Miss Clutton who manned the exchange desk at the library. The standard of the novels never seemed to matter. I can only remember a few times when he put a book down with the words 'This is utterly bogus – I can't finish it!' ... He only liked novels – he would not read poetry or biography. He loved thrillers and magazines, particularly Time magazine.'
Well, at least he drew the line at C.P. Snow (but why Simenon?). The voracious reader described above, by his son Sebastian, is Henry Yorke, better known as the esteemed novelist Henry Green, author of Living, Loving, Party Going and more. Sadly he seems, from this account, to be a reader who has given up on really reading: as Sebastian notes, 'He never re-read a book or selected one from his small library of 'classics' collected in his Oxford days. Nor can I recall him reading anything by his professed idols: Gogol, Turgenev, Doughty, Céline or Faulkner.'
  The reminiscence is taken from a volume I picked up recently in (where else?) a charity bookshop – Surviving: Stories, Essays, Interviews, an NYRB volume complete with an introduction by John Updike. I thought I'd have a look at it to see if it would make me feel any more warmly towards Green, a novelist whose works have always defeated me, much though I, at some level, admire them for their originality and skill. They somehow leave me cold, perhaps because there is so little warmth in them, or so little humour. This is probably unfair.
  Surviving contains some good stuff in the way of short stories and fragments, with some interesting thoughts on writing. There's a vivid portrait of Edward Garnett, who helped launch Green's career, and a fine essay on C.M. Doughty (Travels in Arabia Deserta), whose prose he hugely admired.  Most of the journalism collected here is routine stuff. For me, the best things in the collection are Green's memories of serving in the Auxiliary Fire Service at the height of the London Blitz, with great swathes of the city on fire, and death and destruction all around: A Rescue is particularly memorable. Overall, I'm afraid this volume left me feeling no more warmly towards the author, who is probably in the end simply 'not for me'. I've tried. 

4 comments:

  1. This is exactly right. One of those writers one wishes to like for unfathomable (those short stories aside) reasons. Recently read two of his novels, then re-read some Waugh, and realised that posterity’s judgement has much to recommend it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, Waugh (or some Waugh) will surely be read for pleasure generations hence. I'm not sure anyone ever read Green for pleasure, and as Stevens said of his Supreme Fiction, 'It must give pleasure'.

      Delete
  2. I would not have thought it was possible to love Time. "Voracious reader", sounds like "devout Catholic", something used far more in the third person than the first. I read a fair bit, and know several persons who read more, but I don't think I've ever heard the word "voracious", let alone the term "voracious reader" used by any of them.

    The American novelist and critic W.M. Spackman speaks well of Green, and I have often been pleased by such of his commendations as I have followed up. Green is an exception. But one of Spackman's novels, An Armful of Warm Girl may approach Green's style--it has been a while since I read it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. An Armful of Warm Girl is a fine title – I might just have to seek that out... and Yes, for anyone to love Time magazine seems strange indeed. Thanks George.

      Delete